|
| Reviews
|
Biography
Greg Segal has been
involved in progressive music since the late 70s, writing and
recording his own music independently. His first serious
recording project was with the all improvisational group Paper
Bag, which met with success throughout the 1980s and released
a number of albums on the SST label. Simultaneously, Segal
began to record and release his own solo albums on cassette
throughout the time period, up through and beyond Paper Bag's
semi retirement in 1991. This releases are all now
commercially unavailable. In 1993 he established the improvisational
duo Jugalbandi with drummer Hyam Sosnow, conceived as a Western
counterpart to the tabla/sitar duo set up of Indian classical
music, a project which has existed on and off into the present.
Segal has recently
returned to the solo arena with a pair of releases. Always
Look on the Dark Side of Life is a compilation of selected
tracks from his cassette only independent albums, remastered
for CD, while In Search of the Fantastic is his all new
studio album.
- Greg Northrup [March 2002]
Source: Greg Segal Official
Homepage
Always
Look on the Dark Side of Life - Selected Recordings (1984-1993)
Though
it's generally not the policy of the Giant Progweed to review
compiliations, the commercial inavailibility of any of these original
recordings makes it neccesary in the case of Greg Segal's solo
career retrospective, Always Look on the Dark Side of Life.
Representing a decade long ouvere, the compilation presents
a vastly different side to Segal to those familiar with the improv
duo Jugalbandi. Indeed, much of the material is typically
in the singer songwriter vein, as opposed to the textured sound
collages of his other band. Consistently despondent and
melancholy, the general tone and lyrical themes are often reminiscient
of Peter Hammill to my ears, and his work is nothing if not hearfelt
and expressive. Unfortunately, I don't find the material
particularly strong in its own right. The vocal preponderence
calls for catchier, more compelling melodies than are offered,
and the sound quality and overall performance is demo-ish at best.
Indeed, opening instrumental "As the Sky Turns to Fire" made me
perk up on first listen, and upon further listens revealed itself
as among the strongest cuts on the album. The most traditionally
"prog" piece present, it tears through a number of catchy organ
themes quite successfully. Unfortunately, the vocal-oriented
tracks kick in and for the most part don't go away. The
vast majority of the music is played entirely Segal, by way of
overdubbing various instruments atop one another. It shouldn't
sound like that though, and unfortunately it does, as many
points lack cohesive grooves and sound pasted together.
The best part of this retrospective is the guitar playing, as
the titillatingly short "Discharge" illustrates, with its spacey
atmosphere and intriguing tape effects, along with numerous other
solos and motifs that dot the recordings ("Introduction", "The
Taker"). The worst part are the drums and the vocals, which
often sound out of tune or hurredly applied. On a more positive
note, the songs do seem to get better as they go along.
The material from Water from the Moon, like the somber
solo that closes out "I was Back in School Again" or the atmospheric
outro of "Water from the Moon" shows a tangible step forward overall.
"Motifs" presents what is perhaps the most intriguing vocal melody
of the whole record, along with with an overt nod to Hammill circa
Silent Corner. Overall, Always Look on the Dark
Side of Life is an interesting look at one man's musical development
over the course of a decade. From a purely musical standpoint
however, it honestly sounds like a collection of demos that might
not have been appropriate for commercial release. Alot of
good ideas mixed in with alot of bad or ponderous ones.
And the good material cries to be fleshed out and given appropriate
production, with a full band and vocalist to complement Segal's
guitar work. -
Greg Northrup [March 2002]
Click
Here for Tracklist and Lineup Info
In
Search of the Fantastic (2002)
Ahh... now this
is more like it. Everything that I liked about Greg Segal's
retrospective Always Look on the Dark Side of Life is
expanded upon and brought to fruition on this, his latest full
length offering. In sum, In Search of the Fantastic
completely parts ways with the vocally oriented, sing-songy
material of his previous solo work, and concentrates on what
he does best, creating atmospheric, emotionally charged soundscapes
using electric guitar, minimal percussion and an army of exotic
instruments and electronic effects. The difference is
striking. There are no vocals on the entire album, save
for the reading of Edgar Allan Poe's "Alone" at its opening.
Beyond this, Segal moves through a variety of themes and musical
styles throughout, often sounding improvisational, but clearly
placing the music within some kind of compositional framework.
Early Tangerine Dream, circa Zeit and Atem, is
a convenient reference point for some of the tunes, but doesn't
cover the gamut of what the album has to offer, as the groovy,
distorted bass licks of "The Bad Ass Ride" indicate. In
Search of Fantastic will be a little hard to swallow for
some. Sure, it's abstract, it's dense, it's self-consciously
experimental, but is it any good?
Ultimately, I
think the album succeeds based on its knack for textural variance,
by way of its sheer array of sounds and effects, as well as
Segal's ability to place a conventional melody here and there
to peek through the gloomy ambiance. An enjoyable release
that will hopefully clue us in as to the future course of Segal's
musical endeavors.
- Greg Northrup [March 2002]
|
|